Joomla Sport Template

Judge Darrow's empty courtroom.

Although James Ray's day in court inches closer, there are many legal hurdles and hearings to overcome before that day finally arrives. As a matter of fact, the paperwork and ensuing requests for copies became so overwhelming that the Clerk of the Superior Court in Yavapai County, Jeanne Hicks, issued a press release stating that a link has been added to the Clerk's website for the media and public to easily access documents filed in high profile cases.

Hicks explained in her press release, "The need for such a website quickly became evident when the various news agencies began contacting her offices for information and copies of documents in the State vs. James Arthur Ray case filed earlier this week.

"Ms. Hicks’ staff worked with the IT staff of the Administrative Office of the Courts of the Supreme Court of Arizona and the MIS staff of Yavapai County to develop the link. As documents are filed, clerk staff will upload them into the site enabling the media and the public to view and print documents from their own computers."

While this new page is enormously helpful, there are so many documents flying back and forth between attorneys and judges that it is easy to get overwhelmed quickly.

Here's a summary of the current proceedings and where things stand at this point, including links to all documents since February 9, 2010:

Regarding Bail, Currently Set at $5 million

Originally, the Motion for an Expedited Hearing on Reduced Bail was supposed to be heard on February 12 before Judge Darrow. Bail Hearing Request

When the Gag Order schedule was set, the expedited bail hearing was set aside. See: 2/9/10 Amended Notice of Hearing/Oral Argument

February 10, 2010, the Defense has requested again that there be a hearing on Friday, February 12, 2010 regarding release conditions. Judge Darrow orders that the regular briefing schedule be followed. Specifically, "The Court will not hear the issue of release modification at the hearing set for this Friday." (referring to 2/12/10) See: Status Conference

Hearing on bail set for Febraury 23, 2010 at 3:00 pm, allotting 2 hours. See Order Setting Hearing

Gag Order

The State requested that the Judge impose a gag order on all parties associated with the case. This hearing was set for Friday, February 12, with responses due February 10, 2010. See:2/9/10 Amended Notice of Hearing/Oral Argument

On February 9, 2010, KPNX Broadcasting Co. and Phoenix Newspapers, Inc. requested the opportunity to oppose the gag order request. See: Application from KPNX, Phx. Newspapers

On February 11, 2010, the Defense files an Opposition to State's Request for order directing all parties to refrain from extra-judicial comments "gag order". See Opposition Memorandum

Also on February 11, 2010, the State responds to the KPNX application. (It also has further responses, but the documentation is not complete.) See: Response to KPNX

February 12, 2010, Defense attorneys files a Further Response to "correct a serious legal error in the State's Reply to Defendant's Opposition Re: Request to REstrain Extra-Judicial Statements." (only page 1 is included) See Further Response

February 12, 2010 - Hearing held at 3:00 pm. (See Prescott eNews article:

Cameras In the Courtroom

February 11, the State responds to requests by media for cameras in the courtroom for the February 12 hearing. See State Response to Cameras (only has page 1)

Judge Warren R. Darrow Assigned to the James Arthur Ray Case

Top Yavapai Superior Court Judge Robert M. Brutinel assigns the State vs. James Arthur Ray case to Judge Warren R. Darrowfor "all further proceedings". See Reassignment of Judge

Early Disposition Court Hearing Vacated; Case Management Conference Set

On February 9, the Early Disposition Court hearing for February 11 was vacated. A Case Management Conference was set for March 15, 2010 at 9 am. See: Order Vacating EDC, Setting Case Management and Rule 12.10(a)5.8 Notice

Initial Evidence Disclosure Statement

The State files its Initial Disclosure Statement regarding evidence provided to Defendant (See: Initial Disclosure Statement). This is the material and information was provided:

• Department Report and Supplements 1-129
• Property and Evidence Reports
• Names and Addresses of experts who have examined any evidence in this case
• Dr. Robert E. Lyon, Yavapai County Medical Examiner's Office, 980 Division St., Prescott AZ
  • Autopsy on James Shore, Autopsy Report on Kirby Brown
• Dr. A. L. Mosley, Coconino County Medical Examiner's Office, 2500 N. Fort Valley Rd, Flagstaff, AZ
  • Autopsy on Elizabeth Neuman

James Ray Defense Attorneys

On February 10, 2010, at 4:41 pm, Judge Darrow grants a request to allow Attorneys Luis Li and Truc Do permission to make temporary appearances in behalf of James Arthur Ray.

See: Status Conference

Request for Ruling Regarding Public Records Request

February 12, 2010: Evidently, some media outlet put in a Public Records Request for Ray's phone calls while incarcerated. The State's position is that such telephone calls are not public records under the Arizona Public Records Law. See State's Request for Court Determination

February 12, 2010: The State is also asking for a determination as to whether the autopsy reports and photographs of the autopsies of the three deceased victims is subject to the Public Records requests. The State's position is that only limited information should be disclosed, and the privacy interests of the families should have a higher priority than public interest in disclosure. See State's Request for Court Determination for Review of Autopsy Report

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this comment's feed